Strength Evaluation
Which of the following two arguments is stronger?
Argument A

According to more than two dozen humanitarian and government officials interviewed by CNN, Israel has imposed arbitrary and contradictory criteria for aid entry. The prohibited items include anesthetics and anesthesia machines, oxygen cylinders, ventilators, and water filtration systems. Other items stuck in bureaucratic limbo include dates, sleeping bags, cancer medications, water purification tablets, and maternity kits.

The IDF itself has indicated that they prevent the entry of certain items due to their potential dual-use. While the examples they provide may not include food items, this confirms the existence of a policy that is likely being interpreted arbitrarily.

Argument B

The interviews conducted by Human Rights Watch, a world-renowned organization, suggest Gazans are deliberately denied access to food and water

Overview